How to use
Olive oil for salad: three basic dressings
Three parts oil to one part acid. The rest is easy.
11 October 2026 · 3 min read
Bottled dressings usually carry sugar, emulsifiers, preservatives and cheap seed oil. Making your own takes two minutes, costs less, and lets the olive oil itself come through.
The base ratio
Three parts olive oil to one part acid — lime juice, vinegar or lemon. Add salt and pepper. Shake in a sealed jar or whisk with a fork until combined. Every recipe below is a variation on that ratio.
If it tastes too sharp, add oil. If it tastes oily, add acid. Go slowly and taste as you adjust — this is not baking, nothing will be ruined.
1. Lime and salt
Three tablespoons olive oil, one tablespoon lime juice, a pinch of sea salt, black pepper. Good on cucumber, tomato and red onion — the most familiar combination on a Malaysian table.
2. Garlic and black pepper
Three tablespoons olive oil, one tablespoon vinegar, one crushed garlic clove, coarsely ground black pepper. Leave ten minutes so the garlic infuses, then lift the clove out if you want it gentler.
3. Honey and mustard
Three tablespoons olive oil, one tablespoon vinegar, one teaspoon mustard, one teaspoon honey. The mustard helps the dressing hold together instead of separating. Sweeter, and good on salads with chicken, fruit or nuts.
4. Calamansi and chilli
Three tablespoons olive oil, one tablespoon calamansi juice, one red chilli finely sliced, a pinch of salt. This is the version closest to a local palate, and it works poured over grilled fish or roast chicken as well as over salad.
Why dressings separate, and how to fix it
Oil and acid do not mix on their own. When you shake them, small droplets of acid scatter through the oil, but those droplets rejoin and the two layers re-form within a few minutes. That is normal, not a sign you did something wrong.
There are two answers. The first: shake it again before pouring, and accept that it will separate. The second: add something that holds the two together — a teaspoon of mustard, a little honey, or a teaspoon of yoghurt. These are emulsifiers, and mustard is the most effective at this small a scale.
One more thing that helps: add the oil a little at a time while whisking, rather than pouring it all in at once. A dressing built slowly holds together for longer.
Matching dressing to salad
- Soft leaves like butter lettuce: lime and salt, poured thinly so the leaves do not wilt
- Cucumber, tomato, red onion: lime and salt, or calamansi and chilli
- Salads with chicken or nuts: honey and mustard, which is robust enough to carry heavier ingredients
- Roast vegetables left to cool to warm: garlic and black pepper
- Savoury fruit salads such as green papaya: calamansi and chilli
One useful rule: dress at the last moment. Salt and acid draw water out of leaves, so a salad tossed ten minutes early will have wilted by the time it reaches the table.
Keeping it
A dressing without fresh ingredients like garlic keeps in a sealed jar in the cupboard for a few days. If it contains garlic or fresh herbs, refrigerate it and use within two days. The oil may thicken when cold — leave it at room temperature a few minutes and shake again.
Use extra virgin for dressings. The "pure" and "light" grades have been refined and will not give the same flavour, because flavour is precisely what refining removes.

